How pleasant to see a departure from the Brown Man Review Brown Book rule; here, Pankaj Mishra gets to review David Foster Wallace’s Consider The Lobster for The NYT:

Writing in the late 1920’s, Musil recalled a recently superseded culture in which greatness “was exemplified by a person whose courage was moral courage, whose strength was the strength of a conviction, whose steadfastness was of heart and virtue, and who regarded speed as childish . . . and agility and verve as contrary to dignity.”
Wallace does not have this sense of history, which was indispensable to a moralist like Musil — or, indeed, Mencken, Wallace’s precursor in the distinguished American tradition of boisterous iconoclasm. What he has instead is nostalgia, for a time when writers possessed moral courage and conviction, and it is no less affecting. Still, it doesn’t seem to liberate him entirely from the prejudices and assumptions of his own historical moment — and class. Something of the graduate-school seminar room still clings to his worldview.