SV: The most feared book in the world

(First published in Speaking Volumes, Business Standard, July 26, 2005)

Even though eighty years have elapsed since he wrote it, Adolf Hitler’s Mein Kampf is still legally banned in Germany. And we fear the ghost of Hitler so greatly that few wish to mark, or even acknowledge, the anniversary of Mein Kampf ‘s publication. You may hate the book and its author, but it would have to be included on any list of books that changed the world.

The first part of Mein Kampf was published under the title Eine Abrechnung ( A Reckoning ) on July 18, 1925. The second part came out in 1926. Hitler’s preferred title was Four-and-a-Half Years of Struggle Against Lies, Stupidity and Cowardice : his German publisher sensibly condensed this to My Struggle . Mein Kampf had few readers–the style was as rambling, hectoring and unwieldy as Hitler’s original title indicated. A bare 9,000 copies sold in 1925, though by 1930, sales had reached a respectable 54,000. In 1933, after Hitler won the election, the book sold an estimated 1.5 million copies.

As Mein Kampf sold briskly, other books burned. On May 10, the Nazis held mass bonfires of books that expressed an “un-German” spirit. Works by Marx, Freud, Proust, John Dos Passos, Brecht, Helen Keller, Hemingway, Einstein, Thomas Mann and Jack London were consigned to the flames. Photographs from that time show huge bonfires surrounded by exulting students. A quote from Heinrich Heine was passed around at the time; no one knew how grimly apposite it would be: “Where one burns books, one will soon burn people.”

In Hitler’s Germany, Mein Kampf was a bestseller: a copy was given to every German couple who got married, every Nazi was expected to own the book. By 1945, eight million copies of the book had sold.

Today, Mein Kampf is still widely available everywhere, bar Germany. It is many things: an artifact of fear and loathing, a symbol of unspeakable evil, an index of how far we really believe in free speech. When sales of the book spiked in Turkey this summer, some saw it as an indication of a growing tendency towards fundamentalism.

It’s hard to read Mein Kampf as just a book; the terrible history its author imposed on Europe and the ghosts of the Holocaust haunt every line of it. But this depressing document, blending paranoia with appalling hostility and badly constructed arguments, must be read so that we don’t forget the banality of evil. Hitler wrote in vitriol: “Was there any form of filth or profligacy without at least one Jew involved in it? If you cut even cautiously into such an abscess, you found, like a maggot in a rotting body, often dazzled by the sudden light-a kike!”

These statements, like Hitler’s championing of an abhorrent nationalism, his obssession with the “master race” and his advocating of mass propaganda, have been analysed all too often. Rereading Mein Kampf , what struck me was a passage where Hitler explained his philosophy of reading: “For reading is no end in itself, but a means to an end…. a man who possesses the art of correct reading will….instinctively and immediately perceive everything which in his opinion is worth permanently remembering, either because it is suited to his purpose or generally worth knowing. Once the knowledge he has achieved in this fashion is correctly coordinated within the somehow existing picture of this or that subject created by the imaginations it will function either as a corrective or a complement…”

For years, I’ve seen Mein Kampf as the work of a bad writer; now I see it as the work of a terrifyingly bad reader. Hitler looked for nothing in literature but confirmation of his own narrow, inhuman views, and because he blinkered his vision so well, he found only confirmation, not illumination, certainly not compassion.

Over the years, Mein Kampf has lost its readership–only the bigoted, those with closed hearts and minds, find any kind of enlightenment in its pages. For the rest of us, what those pages reveal is a thin, peevish voice, one that blends self-pity with hatred in repulsive fashion. But the books Hitler’s armies burned that day in May, those books are still read, still discussed, still enjoyed, still alive. The Fuehrer is dead; it’s time to lay the ghost of his bad writing to rest as well.

5 comments

  1. Some thoughts on your efforts, ma’m.First, I suspect people don’t comment on your posts because they are just a little intimidated.Second, you do realise that putting your published work on the blog is like feeding us from doggy-bags? Some fresh stuff once in a while would be very welcome. I for one read you in the Telegraph.The piece on the cashew girls is outstanding, both as description and as comment. Your insight on Mein Kampf as the work of a reader with tunnel vision is wonderful.J.A.P.

  2. Very well written post! When I think about it, I do not think Mein Kampf was written for the sake of literature. The book I think was more a medium to reach the masses, the same way Television is used today.

  3. J. Alfred, always a pleasure to have you drop by. People, intimidated? By ME? (Preening and looking in the mirror…) I take your point about the doggy bag, but well, the reason I put up Akhond was as an archive for my published work, nothing more. It’s great to have people drop by (always makes me want to put the coffee on, get out the cake, put feet up, chat…), but honestly, A of S is really here for selfish reasons, so I can keep track of what I’m writing and for whom, and also because many newspapers don’t have easily accessible online archives, so I keep losing my stuff.I love reading personal blogs, but it would be very difficult for me to sustain one myself. There’s the time thing–Kitabkhana and Animal Rights India both suffer greatly whenever deadlines, travel and other mundane stuff come up, which is often, and perhaps it was a little ambitious to try and keep a third blog going. The other reason I’d be terrible at personal blogging is, well, reticence. I have something to say in my columns, my reviews and my articles, but I’m not ALL that fascinating in person 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s